Photo credit: TechCrunch
Remember when, last October, we’ve been telling you about Nest, the company founded by ex-Apple Chief Architect Tony Fadell, who wanted to enter the market with a revolutionary smart thermostat? Yes, the thermostat has been innovative, but its conception is now contested by none other than Honeywell, who filed a lawsuit against Nest for more than seven patent infringements.
A fresh startup, Nest is backed by Google Ventures (perhaps there’s a link between Fadell and Google’s Eric Schmidt, an ex-Apple board member), Kleiner Perkins and Al Gore (also a board member at Apple) and has gathered some tens of millions of dollars for developing the smart thermostat that they’re now selling through retailer Best Buy, who was also mentioned in the lawsuit.
While I don’t think Honeywell sued for nothing, I also think Nest hasn’t stolen any ideas voluntarily. Among the multitude of innovations Honeywell may have had at some points in time, there may have been more than one resembling Nest’s, but that doesn’t necessarily gives them the moral right to sue, especially if they haven’t brought any of those ideas to the market and probably never will.
Have you ever seen the movie “Tucker: The Man and His Dream?” Well, if you haven’t, I recommend it. What’s happening now to Nest is like taken from the movie, but I don’t want to believe it’ll have the same ending – it would be like putting a cap on innovation and killing it from its infancy.
Nest will defend itself, that’s for sure, but for how long? Katie Fehrenbacher from GigaOM has a few more details on what’s behind the curtains.
Liked it? Share onFacebook and Google +1:
| |  No comments yet.Break the ice! |  E-mail Updates |  |
| Also share story on: | Become our facebook fan |
Read next:
Ex-Apple Chief Architect Designs Nest, The World's Smartest ThermostatTony Fadell, once Apple’s chief architect, the one who was in charge of developing the iPod and the first three versions of iPhone, now has his own company and does only one little thing: a thermostat. Sounds simple, doesn’t it? But Nest, the world’s maybe most expensive and complex thermostat is not at all something [...]
Apple Patents Embedded Solar Panel in Upcoming iPhonesApple has got us used to innovations and brilliant design in all of their products, being them hardware of software. By wanting to stay on the trendy wave of being green (and possibly wanting to make a difference), Apple has filed a patent of a solar powered iPhone. But it’s not the usual solar panel they dream of.
Smart's Ebike To Be Launched By End of 2011A few months ago, Smart has unveiled an amazing electric car concept dubbed ForSpeED, at the 2011 Geneva Motor Show. Now, the same company said it is planning to launch its first electrically assisted bicycle, unveiled at the Paris Auto Show a year ago. According to the automaker, the near-production ready version of their electric [...]
Apple-Patented Fuel Cell Innovation Could Make Portable Devices Lighter & More PowerfulApple has always been seen as the leader in technical innovation of the IT sector. Now Apple seems to getting involved in more than just IT: hydrogen fuel cells… …for computers, that is. The Cupertino-based company has patented in April two ways which describe how fuel cells could be made smaller, lighter and more efficient [...]
Japan Planning A Really Smart Grid Worth Envying and FollowingAn article I just read, written by Technology Review, shows how the Japanese want to amaze us, the rest of the world, over and over again. Not only they’re stuffed with the latest gadgets not yet found anywhere else, but now they want to set an example for the US and Europe to follow.
Comments from our readers
3167 total comments so far. What's your opinion ?- No comments on this article yet.
